Mistaken Belief: “Each Of The [Plural Noun]” Is Plural
It is a common misconception among both learners and native speakers that when the phrase “each of the [plural noun]” is used, it implies a plural meaning. However, this belief is misguided as “each” is always singular, except for certain contrived contexts.
Let us delve deeper into why this misconception persists and the confusion it generates.
Contrived Contexts
In rare situations, when a speaker is intentionally implying separate individuals within a group, they may use a plural form. For example, “Each of the students have their own opinions.” However, this usage is more of an exception and is not reflective of the general rule.
Confusion With Prepositional Phrases Ending In A Plural Word
The confusion around the singular nature of “each” arises when it is followed by a prepositional phrase ending in a plural word. This is due to the misconception that the plural word impacts the agreement of the subject and the verb.
However, this is not the case, as “each” remains singular regardless of the word it is associated with.
Misleading Agreement
Consider the phrase “Each of the students determines their own fate.” It may seem logical to assume that since “students” is plural, the verb “determines” should also be plural. Unfortunately, this is grammatically incorrect.
The subject “each” governs the agreement of the verb, requiring it to be singular. Thus, the correct form should be “Each of the students determines their own fate.”
Historical Usage Of “Each” Followed By A Plural Noun
It is worth noting that in older English, the usage of “each” followed by a plural noun was more common. This has led to the persistence of confusion in modern times.
However, it is crucial to recognize the evolution of language and adhere to the contemporary rules of grammar.
Outdated Forms
Examples such as “Each of the horses have their own stable” were once considered acceptable. Nevertheless, modern grammar conventions dictate that these forms are incorrect.
Conforming to the current language norms ensures clarity and coherence in communication.
Valid Instances Of “Each” Followed By A Plural Noun
While the general rule remains that “each” is singular, there are valid instances where it can be followed by a plural noun. These instances occur in specific contexts and are not as widespread as the mistaken belief indicates.
Verb Agreement With “Each” In “Each Of Us”
The phrase “Each of Us” poses a unique challenge when it comes to subject-verb agreement. Despite “each” being singular and “us” being plural, the entire phrase is considered singular.
This can be a source of confusion, leading to errors in verb agreement.
Correct Agreement
When using the phrase “Each of Us,” the verb that follows should agree with the singular subject “each.” Therefore, the correct form is “Each of Us Has.” This is consistent with the rule that “each” is always singular, regardless of the perceived plurality of the subsequent noun.
Incorrect Form: “Each Of Us Have”
Mistakenly, many individuals use the incorrect form “Each of Us Have” due to the plural nature of “us.” However, this is a grammatical error that should be avoided. The verb should always align with the singular “each” rather than the plural “us.”
Importance Of Using Correct Form In Grammar Emphasized
Accurate grammar is crucial for effective communication. Using the correct form when dealing with phrases like “Each of Us” ensures clarity and precision in conveying our thoughts and ideas.
By adhering to the grammatical rules surrounding the use of “each,” we can elevate our writing and speaking skills, facilitating better understanding and preventing ambiguity.
Influencing Clarity
Using the correct verb agreement in phrases like “Each of Us Has” helps maintain clarity, allowing the reader or listener to easily comprehend the intended meaning. On the other hand, incorrect usage can lead to confusion and potential misinterpretation.
In conclusion, the belief that “each of the [plural noun]” implies a plural meaning is mistaken. “Each” is always singular, and its agreement with the verb remains unaffected by the subsequent noun.
While there are historical instances where “each” was followed by a plural noun, current language conventions prescribe using the singular form. Ensuring proper subject-verb agreement in phrases like “Each of Us” is essential for maintaining grammatical accuracy and effective communication.
So remember, the power to change the world lies not only within each of us but also within our correct use of grammar.
